WEST VINCENT TOWNSHIP
PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES
July 16, 1998
ATTENDING: Chairman James Wendelgass, Vice
Chairman Kate Damsgaard, Members Wheeler Aman, Vince Kling, Joan
Michaelson, and Jean Warrick.
Chairman James Wendelgass called the meeting to order at 7:40 p.m.
The following correspondence was reviewed:
- James W. Gerlach - A report on the Groundwater
Management Conference was received. The conference was designed to be a
comprehensive examination of Pennsylvania’s groundwater system. The
agenda focused on the existing management structure and considered
various options on how to better assess and protect our groundwater
resources.
- PA Historical and Museum Commission - The West
Vincent Highlands Historic District was listed in the National Register
of Historic Places on May 7, 1998.
- DEP Correspondence - Mrs. Loftus, Conestoga Road,
was notified the compounds associated with gasoline contamination were
identified in the water collected from the holding tank, prior to the
filtration system in place at her residence (the filtration system on
the well appears to be adequately removing the gasoline contamination
from the water). DEP is currently investigating the possible sources
for this contamination. The former owner of Cullens Country Cupboard 2
and the Exxon Company, U.S.A. have been requested to submit well survey
data, no later than September 4, 1998, to assist in the effort to
determine the source for the contamination discovered at neighboring
properties.
- Allan Greenwood, Esq. - requesting Morgan Brothers
Builders, Inc. to take corrective action to rectify the problems with
stormwater basin No. 2.
- Northern Federation's Sustainable Watershed Management,
Phase II Implementation - The Planning Commission will review
translating the water numbers into a land use reality, specifically the
existing criteria of Q7-10 and the proposed criteria for first order
streams. Consultants will be invited to address these issues at the
August meeting. Geoscience Associates, Inc. review of the
Sustainable Watershed Management report and Castle Valley
Consultants, Inc. review of the draft stormwater management ordinance
will be sent to members prior to the August meeting.
- DEP - Letter of notification informing the Township
that the Environmental Quality Board approved regulatory amendments that
changed the designated uses of certain water bodies in the municipality.
(Birch Run Basin proposed designation Exceptional Value Waters)
The Planning Commission, EAC and Board of supervisors will hold a
joint work session on Monday, July 20, 1998 at 7:30 p.m.
to review and discuss the Zoning Ordinance and Subdivision and Land
Development Ordinance public hearing comments.
Chairman Wendelgass reviewed the following correspondence regarding
zoning issues:
- Land Planner Randall Arendt - Response to major
comments at the third public hearing.
- Ronald C. Nagle, Esq. - Zoning classification of the
Zarichniak property, Birchrun Road.
- East Vincent Township - Group Homes section of the
Zoning Ordinance.
- Craig Hannafin - Section 2108-Lighting and the need
to address the problem of uplighting; also included were a copy of an
outdoor lighting ordinance adopted by Branford, CT and a model ordinance
template designed by the Illuminating Engineering Society of North
America.
- Realtors Southeast Regional Public Affairs Dept. -
comments regarding Section 2003 - Real Estate Signs.
- David Kusner - Review comments on the draft Zoning
Ordinance and suggested definitions.
- Darrell M. Hoffman, VMD - Zoning classification of
five lots in the area of Blackhorse Road and Pottstown Pike.
- 32 letters from Township residents regarding TDR Sending and
Receiving Zone.
- A draft copy of an ordinance establishing and adopting the
"Official Map" of PA Route 100 By-Pass Corridor
was received.
- The Township has been requested by the Chester County Health
Department to oversee the temporary pump and haul system at the
Helen Wade Parke property; a Sewage Holding Facilities
Agreement and escrow account have been finalized. Formal written
notification of the chosen long-term alternative will be submitted to
DEP by July 24, 1998.
- The Zoning Hearing Board will meet Tuesday, August 18, 1998 to
consider the application of Nextel Communications for
construction of a 180' monopole tower; the application was coupled with
a challenge to the validity of the Zoning Ordinance.
- The Zoning Hearing Board formal decision on the Michael E.
Wozniak application was received.
- Tomlinson Fort, St. Andrews Lane, regarding the
Polay appeal.
The Board of Supervisors granted final approval of the Matthews
Run Subdivision Plan during their Friday, June 26, 1998
Administrative Meeting.
Mr. Steven Siana was present to review the Sheeder Mill
Subdivision Plan, an as-built road plan and one additional lot
to a previously approved 16 lot subdivision plan on 84.2 acres. The
approved plan used the lot averaging design option as permitted in the
RC zoning district. What were Lots 10, 11, and 12 from the approved
plan are now Lots 10, 11, 12, and 13. The road alignment was modified
because of site conditions related to slope and stormwater runoff. The
new road alignment required some minor lot line and lot area
adjustments. Affected Lots 10, 11, 12, and 13 are owned by Mr. Siana; a
.207 acre area will be added to Lot 14 owned by Susan Quigley.
Also present were Kirsten and William S. Hare, owners of Lot 8, and
Douglas McGee, owner of Lot 7. Mr. Siana reviewed a letter written by
David A. Beideman, Beideman Associates, addressing the dimension
discrepancy found on the plan along the Lot 8 property line and the
questions regarding Hunt Hill Road right of way. The property line was
erroneously dimensioned with a typographical error; the correct
dimension of 486.19 feet, as mentioned in the Hare deed and shown on the
original Sheeder Mill subdivision plan, will be corrected on the next
revision to the plan. The location of the cartway of Hunt Hill Road was
also questioned; the detail shows that neither the paved cartway nor
the proposed road right of way encroach into the Hare property.
The Board of Supervisors signed a letter dated August 1, 1994 which
summarized the modifications to the improvements made to Hunt Hill Road
and states "The Township hereby consents to the field change to the
location of Hunt Hill Road and the Developer will provide an "as
built" plan upon completion of the same." Mr. Siana advised
the Planning Commission an overlay was submitted at that time. The
Township files will be reviewed to procure documentation supporting the
Board of Supervisors approved an 0.83' right of way on a section of Hunt
Hill Road and review letters or documentation from the Township Engineer
stating that the reduced right of way is adequate.
The Declaration of Covenants, Easements, Obligations and Restrictions
of Sheeder Mill Subdivision note #7 state "No lot shown on the
record plan shall be further subdivided at any time". The
declaration can be amended.
The Planning Commission will request a legal opinion from Planning
Counsel Fronefield Crawford regarding the following concerns:
- Classification of this plan - i.e. a new subdivision plan,
re-subdivision, amendment to an existing approved plan, or revised plan
- and does it matter what it is called.
- Can an approved subdivision plan, which used the lot averaging
option, be further subdivided? Reference was made to Section 1604 of
the Zoning Ordinance.
- Lot averaging design options require a 5-acre average lot size;
the subdivision into 17 lots as proposed equals a 4.96 acre average lot
size. Is this a Zoning Hearing Board issue or discretionary issue of
the Board of Supervisors?
- Since some of the lots have been sold, will approval be required
from the current lot owners. Will the sold lots be netted out and
recalculations made to accommodate the lot averaging option?
- How do you advise Mr. Siana to proceed?
The following plan revisions/issues were discussed:
- Beideman Associates will confirm the Lot 12 minimum net lot size
area of 5.398 acres.
- Addition of the existing pipeline and horse trail easements on Lot
8.
- Addition of the lot area for Lot 8.
- Percolation test has been completed for Lot 11 per the Chester
County Health Department's request.
- Addition of a note stating the individual grading, stormwater
management and erosion and sedimentation control plans shall be
submitted to West Vincent Township for review and approval at the time
of building permit application.
James Dunworth, equitable owner of the Ordway property,
and Bill Conver, Conver and Smith Engineering, Inc., were present to
review a sketch plan for the 24.8 acre heavily wooded Conestoga Road
property. The plan shows a manufactured house project, possibly
restricted as senior (one spouse over the age of 55) housing, of 114
lots, with a community sewer system and public water proposed. Mr.
Dunworth referred to Buckingham Springs in New Hope as a model for the
"Conestoga Villas" project. Waivers of Subdivision and Land
Development Ordinance Section 611D2a, interior street right-of-way width
and Section 802J1, open space requirements, were requested. The
proposed 20' wide roads will be owned by the park management. The
Ordinance requires 20% open space exclusive of setback and buffer areas
with 50% of open space located in one area; the proposed plan shows
8.42% open space. The southern quarter of the property is an 18-20%
slope area.
The sketch plan shows a minimum lot size of 58' X 85', 2 bedroom/2
bath units approximate size of 28' X 56', building separation of 15' on
each side, and off street parking of five spaces per two units.
Areas of concern include water, utilities, stormwater management,
tree removal and sewer. The Planning Commission suggested a possible
center island and/or significant areas for green space. A site visit is
scheduled for Thursday, July 23 at 4 p.m.
George Robinson was present to review the Robinson Subdivision
Plan, a two lot subdivision plan of a 21 acre tract on Horseshoe
Trail. The final plan revisions will include concrete monuments and two
turnouts spaced 200' along the shared driveway. Motion by Vince Kling,
seconded by Kate Damsgaard, to recommend approval of the Robinson
Subdivision Plan with requested waivers and revisions; the motion
carried unanimously.
Motion by Vince Kling, seconded by Kate Damsgaard, to recommend
approval of the Ludwigs Corner Fire Company Lot Line Change
pending receipt of the signed Form B from the Chester County
Health Department; the motion carried unanimously.
Ellie Brown and Engineer Tracey Borusiewicz were present to review
the Ellie Brown Subdivision Plan. The plan shows 5.120
acres divided into two lots: lot 1, a 2.403 acre proposed residential
lot and lot 2, consisting of 2.717 acres, the Flowing Springs Inn and
parking area. Outstanding issues and concerns include:
- The applicant will delineate steep slope areas on Lot 1.
- Location of the existing well and septic system will be shown on
the plan.
- Per the Zoning Hearing Board Decision, there shall be a physical
separation between the lots; the physical division line intended to
visually separate the uses with the restaurant on one side and the
residential use on the other.
- The names of abutting property owners will be shown on the
plan.
- Sewer, Water and Hydrogeology Study Waiver requests will be added
to the plan.
- Stormwater Management notes recommended in Castle Valley
Consultants review letter dated June 26, 1998, item number six, will be
added to the plan.
- Site Analysis Plan will be submitted.
- Driveway Construction note will be added to the plan stating all
driveway construction Shall comply with all Township standards in effect
at the time of construction.
- Planning Module will be submitted to the Chester County Health
Department.
The applicant will submit a revised preliminary/final plan prior to
the August Planning Commission meeting. A site visit is scheduled for
Thursday, July 23.
There will be no Planning Commission work session in August; the
regular meeting will be held Thursday, August 20, 1998. The minutes
from the June 18, 1998 meeting were unanimously approved with a motion
from Vince Kling and second from Joan Michaelson. The meeting was
adjourned at 10:45 p.m.